האומר לאשתו כל הנדרים שתדורי מכאן עד שאבא ממקום פלוני. הרי הן קיימין. לא אמר כלום. הרי הן מופרין. רבי אליעזר אומר מופר. וחכמים אומרים אינו מופר. אמר רבי אליעזר אם הפר נדרים שבאו לכלל איסור. לא יפר נדרים שלא באו לכלל איסור. אמרו לו הרי הוא אומר (במדבר ל, יד) אישה יקימנו. ואישה יפרנו. את שבא לכלל הקם. בא לכלל הפר. לא בא לכלל הקם. לא בא לכלל הפר:
If a man says to his wife, “All vows which you may vow from now until I return from such and such a place behold, they are upheld,” he has not said anything. [If he said: All vows which you may vow from now until I return from such and such a place], behold, they are annulled,”: Rabbi Eliezer says: they are annulled; The Sages say: they are not annulled. Said Rabbi Eliezer: if he can annul vows which have already had the force of a prohibition, surely he can annul those which have not had the force of prohibition! They said to him: behold, it is said, “Her husband may uphold it, and her husband may annul it” (Numbers 30:14), that which has entered the category of upholding, has entered the category of annulment; but that which has not entered the category of upholding, has not entered the category of annulment.
Comments
Select a line on the left to view commentary.
Help support Theologa. Click to donate now!